When selecting a flow meter filling system, one of the most important decisions is choosing the right measurement technology for your application. While every flow meter is designed to measure product before it enters the container, they do not all measure it the same way. The technology inside the meter directly affects filling accuracy, product compatibility, maintenance requirements, and long-term performance.
There isn’t a single flow meter that’s best for every product. The right choice depends on the characteristics of the liquid being filled, the level of accuracy required, and the demands of your production environment. Understanding how each type of flow meter works and where it performs best can help ensure your filling system delivers consistent results for years to come.
Two of the most common technologies used in liquid filling are magnetic (mag) flow meters and mass flow meters. Both provide accurate, repeatable fills and are designed for sanitary Clean-in-Place (CIP) operation. The difference is how they measure product and the types of liquids they are designed to handle.
Understanding those differences can help you choose the technology that best fits your application.
Magnetic Flow Meters
A magnetic flow meter measures product by volume. The term “mag” refers to the magnetic field the meter uses to calculate the flow rate of a conductive liquid.
Because the technology relies on electrical conductivity, it works well with many water-based products, including beverages, juices, sauces, and other conductive liquids. The single straight measuring tube also makes it a good choice for many products containing particulates since there are fewer areas where solids can collect.
For fill volumes up to 1,000 mL, filling accuracy is maintained within ±2.0 mL at 1σ. Above 1,000 mL, accuracy is maintained within ±0.2% of the target fill volume at 1σ.
Conductivity alone, however, does not guarantee the best fit. Thick products, such as chocolate sauce, can coat the meter’s electrodes over time, reducing performance. In those situations, a mass flow meter may be the better option.
Mass Flow Meters
Mass flow meters measure product by weight using the Coriolis effect. Inside the meter, vibrating tubes detect changes created by the moving liquid, allowing the meter to measure mass directly.
Because this technology does not rely on electrical conductivity, it is commonly used for products such as cooking oils, motor oils, laundry detergents, high-vinegar products, and other non-conductive liquids.
In addition to measuring fill weight, a mass flow meter can also measure density, temperature, and viscosity. Depending on the application, these measurements can provide valuable process data beyond filling alone.
For fill weights up to 1,000 grams, filling accuracy is maintained within ±1.0 g at 1σ. Above 1,000 grams, accuracy is maintained within ±0.1% of the target fill weight at 1σ.
One consideration is the internal design. Product flows through two smaller measuring tubes rather than a single straight tube, making products with larger particulates more likely to clog.
Comparing the Two Technologies
Both magnetic and mass flow meters deliver reliable, repeatable filling performance and are designed for sanitary production environments with Clean-in-Place capability.
At a high level, magnetic flow meters are typically chosen for conductive products, especially those containing particulates. Mass flow meters are often preferred for non-conductive products or applications where filling by weight and additional process measurements are important.
The product itself usually determines the best fit.
| Magnetic Flow Meter | Mass Flow Meter |
| Measures by volume | Measures by weight |
| Requires conductive products | Works with both conductive and non-conductive products |
| Single straight measuring tube | Two vibrating measuring tubes |
| Well suited for many products with particulates | Better suited for products without particulates |
| Lower initial cost | Higher initial cost |
| Measures flow volume | Can also measure density, temperature, and viscosity |
Conclusion
Both magnetic and mass flow meters have proven themselves in liquid filling applications. Neither technology is inherently better than the other. The right choice depends on the product you’re filling and the performance you expect from your equipment. Understanding the strengths of each technology will help you select a system that delivers accurate, reliable results for your application.
Have Questions?
Our team works with customers filling everything from beverages and food products to household and industrial liquids. We’re happy to help you determine which flow meter technology best fits your product.